| Ashland University | Women's | NCAA Division II | Ashland | 8 | $21,988 | 76% |
| Ashland University | Men's | NCAA Division II | Ashland | 8 | $21,988 | 76% |
| Baldwin Wallace University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Berea | 12 | $27,603 | 76% |
| Baldwin Wallace University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Berea | 15 | $27,603 | 76% |
| Bowling Green State University-Main Campus | Women's | NCAA Division I | Bowling Green | 9 | $24,022 | 81% |
| Capital University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Columbus | 12 | $22,576 | 70% |
| Capital University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Columbus | 8 | $22,576 | 70% |
| Case Western Reserve University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Cleveland | 19 | $41,190 | 37% |
| Case Western Reserve University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Cleveland | 13 | $41,190 | 37% |
| Cedarville University | Men's | NCAA Division II | Cedarville | 11 | $24,468 | 65% |
| Cedarville University | Women's | NCAA Division II | Cedarville | 12 | $24,468 | 65% |
| Cleveland State University | Women's | NCAA Division I | Cleveland | 8 | $14,764 | 91% |
| Cleveland State University | Men's | NCAA Division I | Cleveland | 12 | $14,764 | 91% |
| Denison University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Granville | 9 | $40,007 | 17% |
| Denison University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Granville | 15 | $40,007 | 17% |
| Franciscan University of Steubenville | Women's | NCAA Division III | Steubenville | 18 | $23,589 | 58% |
| Franciscan University of Steubenville | Men's | NCAA Division III | Steubenville | 13 | $23,589 | 58% |
| John Carroll University | Men's | NCAA Division III | University Heights | 8 | $28,746 | 81% |
| John Carroll University | Women's | NCAA Division III | University Heights | 8 | $28,746 | 81% |
| Kenyon College | Women's | NCAA Division III | Gambier | 10 | $38,512 | 31% |
| Kenyon College | Men's | NCAA Division III | Gambier | 11 | $38,512 | 31% |
| Lourdes University | Women's | NAIA | Sylvania | 8 | $23,206 | 74% |
| Lourdes University | Men's | NAIA | Sylvania | 7 | $23,206 | 74% |
| Marietta College | Women's | NCAA Division III | Marietta | 5 | $21,083 | 79% |
| Marietta College | Men's | NCAA Division III | Marietta | 5 | $21,083 | 79% |
| Miami University-Oxford | Women's | NCAA Division I | Oxford | 10 | $28,384 | 75% |
| Mount Vernon Nazarene University | Men's | NAIA | Mount Vernon | 8 | $22,421 | 84% |
| Mount Vernon Nazarene University | Women's | NAIA | Mount Vernon | 7 | $22,421 | 84% |
| Oberlin College | Women's | NCAA Division III | Oberlin | 5 | $38,645 | 34% |
| Oberlin College | Men's | NCAA Division III | Oberlin | 7 | $38,645 | 34% |
| Ohio Northern University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Ada | 11 | $24,478 | 74% |
| Ohio Northern University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Ada | 12 | $24,478 | 74% |
| Ohio State University-Main Campus | Men's | NCAA Division I | Columbus | 13 | $17,339 | 61% |
| Ohio State University-Main Campus | Women's | NCAA Division I | Columbus | 11 | $17,339 | 61% |
| Ohio Wesleyan University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Delaware | 7 | $20,897 | 56% |
| Ohio Wesleyan University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Delaware | 9 | $20,897 | 56% |
| Otterbein University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Westerville | 9 | $19,237 | 85% |
| Otterbein University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Westerville | 10 | $19,237 | 85% |
| Shawnee State University | Men's | NAIA | Portsmouth | 12 | $14,381 | — |
| Shawnee State University | Women's | NAIA | Portsmouth | 7 | $14,381 | — |
| The College of Wooster | Men's | NCAA Division III | Wooster | 12 | $23,458 | 60% |
| The College of Wooster | Women's | NCAA Division III | Wooster | 11 | $23,458 | 60% |
| The University of Findlay | Men's | NCAA Division II | Findlay | 13 | $27,221 | 83% |
| The University of Findlay | Women's | NCAA Division II | Findlay | 11 | $27,221 | 83% |
| Tiffin University | Women's | NCAA Division II | Tiffin | 13 | $26,500 | 80% |
| Tiffin University | Men's | NCAA Division II | Tiffin | 14 | $26,500 | 80% |
| University of Cincinnati | Women's | NCAA Division I | Cincinnati | 9 | $25,648 | 85% |
| University of Dayton | Men's | NCAA Division I | Dayton | 12 | $29,533 | 65% |
| University of Dayton | Women's | NCAA Division I | Dayton | 8 | $29,533 | 65% |
| University of Mount Union | Women's | NCAA Division III | Alliance | 10 | $23,280 | 78% |
| University of Mount Union | Men's | NCAA Division III | Alliance | 13 | $23,280 | 78% |
| University of Northwestern Ohio | Women's | NAIA | Lima | 10 | $21,807 | — |
| University of Northwestern Ohio | Men's | NAIA | Lima | 10 | $21,807 | — |
| University of Toledo | Women's | NCAA Division I | Toledo | 9 | $17,249 | 92% |
| University of Toledo | Men's | NCAA Division I | Toledo | 7 | $17,249 | 92% |
| Ursuline College | Women's | NCAA Division II | Pepper Pike | 7 | $16,164 | 75% |
| Walsh University | Women's | NCAA Division II | North Canton | 12 | $20,493 | 71% |
| Walsh University | Men's | NCAA Division II | North Canton | 12 | $20,493 | 71% |
| Wittenberg University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Springfield | 10 | $18,649 | 72% |
| Wittenberg University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Springfield | 9 | $18,649 | 72% |
| Xavier University | Men's | NCAA Division I | Cincinnati | 8 | $32,997 | 86% |
| Xavier University | Women's | NCAA Division I | Cincinnati | 9 | $32,997 | 86% |
| Youngstown State University | Men's | NCAA Division I | Youngstown | 9 | $12,767 | 84% |
| Youngstown State University | Women's | NCAA Division I | Youngstown | 9 | $12,767 | 84% |