| Anderson University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Anderson | 11 | $25,021 | 79% |
| Anderson University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Anderson | 12 | $25,021 | 79% |
| Ball State University | Women's | NCAA Division I | Muncie | 7 | $14,940 | 86% |
| Ball State University | Men's | NCAA Division I | Muncie | 10 | $14,940 | 86% |
| Bethel University | Men's | NAIA | Mishawaka | 18 | $18,610 | 98% |
| Bethel University | Women's | NAIA | Mishawaka | 17 | $18,610 | 98% |
| Butler University | Women's | NCAA Division I | Indianapolis | 9 | $36,041 | 85% |
| Butler University | Men's | NCAA Division I | Indianapolis | 11 | $36,041 | 85% |
| DePauw University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Greencastle | 10 | $22,264 | 57% |
| DePauw University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Greencastle | 15 | $22,264 | 57% |
| Earlham College | Men's | NCAA Division III | Richmond | 9 | $24,714 | 73% |
| Earlham College | Women's | NCAA Division III | Richmond | 7 | $24,714 | 73% |
| Franklin College | Women's | NCAA Division III | Franklin | 7 | $22,855 | 70% |
| Franklin College | Men's | NCAA Division III | Franklin | 19 | $22,855 | 70% |
| Goshen College | Men's | NAIA | Goshen | 9 | $14,493 | 84% |
| Goshen College | Women's | NAIA | Goshen | 8 | $14,493 | 84% |
| Grace College and Theological Seminary | Women's | NAIA | Winona Lake | 10 | $19,932 | 82% |
| Grace College and Theological Seminary | Men's | NAIA | Winona Lake | 12 | $19,932 | 82% |
| Hanover College | Men's | NCAA Division III | Hanover | 11 | $21,829 | 84% |
| Hanover College | Women's | NCAA Division III | Hanover | 7 | $21,829 | 84% |
| Holy Cross College | Women's | NAIA | Notre Dame | 10 | $26,728 | 75% |
| Holy Cross College | Men's | NAIA | Notre Dame | 12 | $26,728 | 75% |
| Huntington University | Men's | NAIA | Huntington | 14 | $19,310 | 76% |
| Huntington University | Women's | NAIA | Huntington | 9 | $19,310 | 76% |
| Indiana Institute of Technology | Women's | NAIA | Fort Wayne | 12 | $23,206 | 70% |
| Indiana Institute of Technology | Men's | NAIA | Fort Wayne | 18 | $23,206 | 70% |
| Indiana University-Bloomington | Men's | NCAA Division I | Bloomington | 12 | $16,264 | 78% |
| Indiana University-Bloomington | Women's | NCAA Division I | Bloomington | 9 | $16,264 | 78% |
| Indiana University-East | Women's | NAIA | Richmond | 8 | $8,134 | 67% |
| Indiana University-East | Men's | NAIA | Richmond | 9 | $8,134 | 67% |
| Indiana University-Indianapolis | Women's | NCAA Division I | Indianapolis | 7 | $11,668 | 76% |
| Indiana University-Indianapolis | Men's | NCAA Division I | Indianapolis | 10 | $11,668 | 76% |
| Indiana University-Kokomo | Women's | NAIA | Kokomo | 9 | $3,968 | 86% |
| Indiana University-Southeast | Men's | NAIA | New Albany | 6 | $7,888 | 84% |
| Indiana University-Southeast | Women's | NAIA | New Albany | 6 | $7,888 | 84% |
| Indiana Wesleyan University-Marion | Women's | NAIA | Marion | 13 | $22,866 | 89% |
| Indiana Wesleyan University-Marion | Men's | NAIA | Marion | 16 | $22,866 | 89% |
| Manchester University | Women's | NCAA Division III | North Manchester | 14 | $18,805 | 71% |
| Manchester University | Men's | NCAA Division III | North Manchester | 9 | $18,805 | 71% |
| Marian University | Women's | NAIA | Indianapolis | 19 | $24,018 | 95% |
| Marian University | Men's | NAIA | Indianapolis | 16 | $24,018 | 95% |
| Oakland City University | Women's | NAIA | Oakland City | 16 | $15,210 | 83% |
| Oakland City University | Men's | NAIA | Oakland City | 25 | $15,210 | 83% |
| Purdue University Northwest | Women's | NCAA Division II | Hammond | 9 | $6,079 | 72% |
| Purdue University Northwest | Men's | NCAA Division II | Hammond | 10 | $6,079 | 72% |
| Purdue University-Main Campus | Men's | NCAA Division I | West Lafayette | 13 | $14,600 | 50% |
| Purdue University-Main Campus | Women's | NCAA Division I | West Lafayette | 8 | $14,600 | 50% |
| Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology | Men's | NCAA Division III | Terre Haute | 19 | $42,513 | 77% |
| Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology | Women's | NCAA Division III | Terre Haute | 9 | $42,513 | 77% |
| Trine University | Women's | NCAA Division III | Angola | 17 | $25,355 | 85% |
| Trine University | Men's | NCAA Division III | Angola | 19 | $25,355 | 85% |
| University of Indianapolis | Men's | NCAA Division II | Indianapolis | 8 | $21,602 | 67% |
| University of Indianapolis | Women's | NCAA Division II | Indianapolis | 7 | $21,602 | 67% |
| University of Notre Dame | Men's | NCAA Division I | Notre Dame | 11 | $26,780 | 11% |
| University of Notre Dame | Women's | NCAA Division I | Notre Dame | 10 | $26,780 | 11% |
| University of Saint Francis-Fort Wayne | Women's | NAIA | Fort Wayne | 8 | $18,196 | 96% |
| University of Saint Francis-Fort Wayne | Men's | NAIA | Fort Wayne | 8 | $18,196 | 96% |
| University of Southern Indiana | Women's | NCAA Division II | Evansville | 12 | $12,923 | 96% |
| University of Southern Indiana | Men's | NCAA Division II | Evansville | 8 | $12,923 | 96% |
| Valparaiso University | Women's | NCAA Division I | Valparaiso | 7 | $18,578 | 89% |